Turtle Brownie Pudding

I had a craving for something chocolatey, gooey and sinful... don't we all at some point? When I saw Ina Garten make the following recipe on her show, Barefoot Contessa, I knew I had to make it. With only a few basic ingredients from a well stocked pantry, I would be an hour away from chocolate decadence. To make it even more enticing, I drizzled some caramel sauce and sprinkled some toasted pecans over this bowl of deliciousness.

Now this dish is not your 'pick up and devour' type of brownie. It's definitely more of a pudding where you'll want to dish this up with a spoon. When it bakes up, the top will have a nice crust to it, similar to a standard brownie recipe, however when serving it up, you'll notice that the texture is like a thick chocolate soup consistency. Don't let it mess with your mind and think it's not done... because that's the way it should be! If you're skeeved out by the runny texture, you can always bake it a little longer to firm up a bit (which I did myself).

Turtle Brownie Pudding
recipe adapted from Ina Garten

1/2 pound (2 sticks) unsalted butter, plus extra for buttering the dish
4 extra-large eggs, at room temperature
2 cups sugar
3/4 cup good cocoa powder
1/2 cup all-purpose flour
Seeds scraped from 1 vanilla bean or 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Vanilla ice cream, for serving
Caramel sauce, for garnish
1/4 cup toasted pecans, for garnish

Preheat the oven to 325 degrees F. Lightly butter a 2-quart (9 by 12 by 2-inch) oval baking dish. Melt the 1/2 pound of butter and set aside to cool.
In the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the eggs and sugar on medium-high speed for 5 to 10 minutes, until very thick and light yellow. Meanwhile, sift the cocoa powder and flour together and set aside.

When the egg and sugar mixture is ready, reduce the speed to low and add the vanilla seeds, and the cocoa powder and flour mixture. Mix only until combined. With mixer still on low, slowly pour in the cooled butter and mix again just until combined.

Pour the brownie mixture into the prepared dish and place it in a larger baking pan. Add enough of the hottest tap water to the pan to come halfway up the side of the dish and bake for exactly 1 hour. A cake tester inserted 2 inches from the side will come out 3/4 clean. The center will appear very under-baked; this dessert is between a brownie and a pudding.

Allow to cool and serve with vanilla ice cream, drizzle with caramel sauce and sprinkle with toasted pecans.


  1. This looks fabulous. A brownie and ice cream with carmel has to be the best thing in the world!

  2. I made brownie pudding last weekend and it was GONE by Sunday night! LOL! Is this not the best dessert on the planet?!! Your Turtle version looks even better!!


  3. I saw this on her show just the other day and also thought to myself, oh I must make this soon. Thanks for posting. I love Ina!

  4. My mouth is watering and it's too late for me to start making this yummy looking treat now. Thanks alot!! :)
    I'll have to have it for lunch tomorrow. Yes, as a meal!! Mmmmm!!!!

  5. I love Ina. Barefoot Contessa is one of my favorite shows. Thank you for the recipe!

  6. This looks so yummy with the ice cream, caramel and nuts!!

  7. My mom used to make a version of those gooey brownies!! I had completely forgotten about them--I'm not quite sure how. :)
    Your toppings make the whole thing sound like the ultimate in decadence.

  8. Yum! This looks like the perfect way to satisfy a chocolate craving!